说不出的——大到、深到、圣到言语接不住的那种;「无以名状」的学名。 Too great, too deep, too holy for words to carry — the proper name of the unnameable.
Too great, too deep, too holy for words to carry — the proper name of the unnameable. 说不出的——大到、深到、圣到言语接不住的那种;「无以名状」的学名。
词源etymology
拉丁语 in-(不)+ effabilis(可说出的)← effari(说出)← fari(说)。 fari 是个高产的根:fate 是「已被说出的」(命运即神谕),fable 是「被讲述的」, ineffable 是「说不出的」——命运、寓言、无言,同一个「说」字养的三兄弟。
Latin in- (not) + effabilis (utterable) ← effari (to speak out) ← fari (to speak). A prolific root: fate is “what has been spoken” (destiny as decree), a fable is “what is told,” and the ineffable is “what cannot be said” — destiny, story and silence, three brothers raised by one verb.
背景the story
14 世纪末进入英语,先在神学里当班:中世纪传统里,神的圣名不可读出—— the ineffable name。此后它一路下放:神秘主义者的狂喜、康德之后的崇高、 游客面对峡谷的失语,都归它管。
对词匣而言它是第三枚元词:lacuna 指语言的缺口,palimpsest 指覆写的旧迹, ineffable 指「说不出」本身——整个匣子收的都是 ineffable 的东西, 而「说不出」这件事,居然说得出。
In English from the late 14th century, first on theological duty: in the medieval tradition the divine name was not to be uttered — the ineffable name. It has been demobilizing ever since: mystics’ raptures, the post-Kantian sublime, tourists struck dumb at the canyon rim all file under it.
For this box it is the third meta-word: lacuna names the language’s gap, palimpsest the overwritten trace, ineffable the unsayable itself — everything this box collects is ineffable, and “unsayable,” it turns out, can be said.
中文里的邻居neighbors in chinese
中文这排货架极满:「无以名状」「不可名状」「妙不可言」「只可意会,不可言传」, 佛家还有加倍的「不可说」。分工却有偏向:中文的不可言说多派给妙—— 意会的那头是会心;ineffable 兼收另一头——numinous 式的战栗与庄严也归它。 一边偏赏玩,一边兼敬畏。
The Chinese shelf is fully stocked: 无以名状, 不可名状, 妙不可言, 只可意会不可言传, and Buddhism’s doubled 不可说. But the assignments lean: Chinese unsayability is mostly issued to the exquisite — what defeats words delights the mind. ineffable also works the other wing — the numinous shudder, the solemn too-much. One tradition leans appreciation; the other covers awe as well.
The canyon at first light reduced the tour group to ineffable grunts. 自拟例句 our own example, not a quotation What she felt at the gate wasn't sadness exactly; it was ineffable, which is why she said nothing and bought coffee. 自拟例句 our own example, not a quotation 词典词(MW/OED),正式写作通用,略带庄重。 写「ineffable joy」这类搭配已近套话——让它守在真正接不住话的地方,词才值钱。
A dictionary word (MW/OED), good anywhere formal, with a ceremonial grain. “Ineffable joy” has worn to a groove — post the word only where language genuinely drops the catch, and it keeps its value.